Welcome to Player Attack!

Apple refunds dad over girl’s £4k in-game bill

Eight-year old British girl Lily Neale loves her dad's iPad. She plays games on it all day: My Horse, Campus Life and Smurfs' Village are among her favourites. She loves these games so much she happily racked up a real-world bill of more than £4,000 in in-game purchases, tapping away at prompts to buy more jewels, coins and upgrades. Her father is somewhat less of a fan.

Smurfs' Village

Smurfs' Village

Email alerts from Apple to Lily's father Lee about the purchases went unnoticed - his iTunes account was registered to his work email address, which he was unable to access.

Lily spent hours on the games, never realising she was also spending real money. Lee's bank, however, knew it was very real - and froze Lee's account after his daughter reportedly spent £2,000 in 74 transactions across just six days.

Lee was faced with the prospect of selling his car to raise money to pay off his daughter's debts, after Apple's initial reaction that "all purchases made on the iTunes store are final".

Apple has since contacted Lee with better news, apologising for closing his case so early and confirming that all of the money will be refunded.

But how was this eight-year old able to run up such a huge bill? Lee admits it was - at least partially - his fault.

Even when I sat her down and explained that what she was doing had cost dad money, I still don’t think she really understood.

Lily apparently watched her Dad using the App Store and remembered his password, which she then entered at the game's prompts.

A similar story happened in the UK in March, where another eight-year old spent £980 on virtual donuts in-game. At the time, Apple reminded customers that these situations are addressed on a case-by-case basis, and refunds are not assured.

To avoid falling into the same trap, Apple suggests that families familiarise themselves with the Parents' Guide to iTunes (requires iTunes software), which touches on topics such as not sharing your passwords with the kids, using iTunes gift cards or certificates instead of credit cards, and enabling Parental Controls or Restrictions.

Why not check out our latest vidcast!
Player Attack TV: October 17 2014, SE2 EP36 or subscribe to our YouTube channel.


  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • email
  • Delicious
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Myspace
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • N4G


  • Follow us on Twitter or like us on Facebook


Get The Latest Episode News
Email Address


4 Responses to “Apple refunds dad over girl’s £4k in-game bill”

  1. JNai says:

    She’s 8 and didn’t understand that it cost REAL money to buy s**t on a iOS game? PLEASE! She understood, she simply didn’t give a f**k! Her parents were also dumb as s**t for not putting the parental controls on.

  2. Trekner says:

    Stupidity/ignorance should not be an excuse to get out of that kind of debt, id almost bet that the dad himself told the kid the password, so that he would not run every time when she asked to play one of the games on his ios. and then again, maybe the game companies should do some thing about some of thier games being quite addictive at times (was it the philipines or korea that made real world laws regarding computer/console games, since some people over there would forget every thing about the real world once they began to play.)

    Basically i think the parents dropped the ball on this.
    Thou companies might want to change and say this is costing real money and not gems, coins, tokens, gold, etc. But its a marketing scheme, to say it costs 500 gems instead of 20£. in other terms they try to hide the real world costs of boosts in thier mini games.

  3. […] is yet to announce if it will offer a refund – similar cases have seen hundreds and thousands of pounds given back to parents, despite apps clearly featuring parental controls to avoid this level of […]

Leave a Comment

Article Details

Author Bio:

I like video games and music and cups of tea and noodles and beagles and colour-cycling LEDs.
Like me on Facebook?

Popular Articles

Subscribe to our Youtube channel and get all the latest TV episodes.