Yes, Australia should have an R18+ rating for computer games

So you might have noticed things around GamePron have been a little quiet of late – but I have a perfectly valid reason excuse. At the end of 2009, I was contracted by Electronic Frontiers Australia (in conjunction with AusGamers to write a discussion paper arguing why Australia should have an R18+ rating for computer games.

Essentially, Australia is the only “western” country to not have an adult rating for computer games – if it’s unsuitable for a 15-year-old, it’s unsuitable for the whole country (this is why we get so many games “banned” Down Under). In December, the Commonwealth Government called for a public consultation on the topic – and that’s where EFA (and I!) get involved, with a document to explain exactly why we should have an adult rating for computer games.

Now, it’s your turn. EFA have published my draft paper, and they want your input. You can read the entire, draft, EFA discussion paper, and make any changes, add any comments, or leave any feedback you feel is appropriate.

This is not the time to get all tl;dr, it’s pretty easy to digest, and has some really interesting tidbits. Did you know that over half of the games that were rated as MA15+ in Australia were given adult ratings by five of the comparable overseas agencies?

As Nic explained over on the EFA blog, the main points we’re trying to stress in the paper are really pretty simple:

• Gamers are adults; games, like films, tell expressive stories, not all of which are suitable for children. Banning everything that is not suitable for children amounts to unacceptable censorship of legitimate expression.
• Gamers are parents; as responsible parents, we take care to monitor what media our children consume, and can take responsibility for those decisions.
• An R18+ rating is about empowerment; the goal of Australia’s classification is to empower adults, protect children, protect people from accidental exposure to offensive material, and to take into account community concerns about particularly offensive content. An R18+ allows adults to choose what is suitable for themselves and for their children.
• An R18+ rating will be more likely to decrease rather than increase the exposure of children to inappropriate content, because it sends a clear message to parents that certain material is not appropriate for children; the lack of an R18+ for games, particularly when one exists for films, only causes confusion and lessens the ability of parents to take responsibility.
• Australia’s system is out of step with the rest of the world; games that are clearly not designed for children are being released with an MA15+ rating, and games that are suitable for adults are being banned. Our research shows that of the 47 games that were rated by the Australian Classification Board, the US ESRB, the UK BBFC, the EU PEGI, and the NZ OFLC, more than 50 per cent of titles that were rated MA15+ in Australia were given an adult rating overseas. The Australian system is demonstrably less effective in warning parents and gamers about the content of video games than our international counterparts. Introducing an R18+ rating will address some of this disparity and enable Australians to make more informed choices about what games they play or allow their children to play.

So. Submissions to the public consultation close at the end of this month, if you want to send in your own response, you can do that either by using Grow Up Australia‘s handy form, or the submission guidelines from the Attorney-General’s Department.

3 Responses to “Yes, Australia should have an R18+ rating for computer games”

1. Australia Needs an R18+ Rating for Games Now – You Need To Get Involved | Geek Actually says:

   February 4, 2010 at 6:50 am

   [...] We here at Geek Actually rant on about censorship issues constantly, one of these issues is the lack of an R18+ rating for games in Australia. The lack of this rating is leading to many games being refused classification (or banned in other terminology) so it is a serious censorship issue. Well, our friends over at Game Pron (hi, Jessica) have put up a wonderful post all about the discussion paper that was released recently and what they are doing. We have discussed the discussion paper before on the podcast and on this blog, Game Pron has even more information. Go to their page by clicking here now. [...]

   Reply
2. Australian Catholic Bishops support R18+ rating « GamePron says:

   May 7, 2010 at 3:52 am

   [...] The Standing Committee of Attorneys General have agreed to release a status report following the public consultation on the matter, and while the results are overwhelmingly for the introduction of an adult [...]

   Reply
3. R18+: No conclusive link between games, violence « GamePron says:

   December 2, 2010 at 11:57 pm

   [...] period was overwhelmed by gamers and sympathisers calling for an R18+ rating (I contributed to a discussion paper that was submitted by Electronic Frontiers Australia and AusGamers). Last month he revealed he [...]

   Reply

Article Details

• published: February 4th, 2010
• by: Jessica Citizen
• in: Adelaide, AusGamers, Australian R18+ Debate, Electronic Frontiers Australia, Politics, Refused Classification
• comments: 3

Author Bio:

I like video games, fishing, Depeche Mode, long walks on the beach, writing discussion papers and cups of tea. Not necessarily in that order.

Popular Articles